Cimarron 1873 Repeating Value Guide

The Cimarron 1873 Repeating is a .357 Mag / .44-40 / .45 Colt firearm built by Cimarron Firearms with a lever-action action. This Cimarron 1873 Repeating value guide covers 2026 private-sale prices across six condition tiers and the configuration variants that move resale value.

What Is My Cimarron 1873 Repeating Worth in 2026?

In 2026, a used Cimarron 1873 Repeating in good condition is worth between $950 and $1,160 in most U.S. private-sale markets. A new-in-box Cimarron 1873 Repeating retails $1,499 to $1,725. The Cimarron 1873 Repeating has held value because of its place in the Cimarron Firearms lineup and steady used-market demand.

Cimarron 1873 Repeating Value by Condition Grade

Use the Cimarron 1873 Repeating value ranges below to estimate resale before listing. Each tier reflects 2026 private-party transactions tracked across major U.S. firearms marketplaces:

• Poor: $505 – $645 — heavy wear, function-only
• Fair: $715 – $875 — visible wear, all parts present
• Good: $950 – $1,160 — light carry/use wear, complete
• Very Good: $1,160 – $1,340 — minimal marks, original case
• Excellent: $1,340 – $1,525 — like-new, all paperwork
• New in Box: $1,499 – $1,725 — unfired, current production

About the Cimarron 1873 Repeating

Cimarron Firearms introduced the Cimarron 1873 Repeating in 1989 as part of the company’s lever-action catalog. Standard configuration: 24″ barrel, 13+1 capacity, .357 Mag / .44-40 / .45 Colt chambering, 8 lbs unloaded weight. The platform is manufactured in Italy.

Why the Cimarron 1873 Repeating Holds Its Value

The Cimarron 1873 Repeating retains value because Cimarron Firearms’s reputation drives steady used demand, and the platform’s specific niche within the lever-action segment keeps competition for clean examples healthy. Used buyers seek the Cimarron 1873 Repeating for its proven configuration and parts availability.

What Affects Cimarron 1873 Repeating Resale Value

Original case completeness adds $30-60. All factory accessories (extra magazines, manuals, locks) add $20-40. Optic-equipped or upgraded variants transfer at 60-70% of upgrade cost. Cosmetic condition matters — clean examples command top of each tier.

Selling Your Cimarron 1873 Repeating — The Smart Sequence

To capture full Cimarron 1873 Repeating value at sale, document the configuration clearly, photograph the bore and key markings, and list with all factory accessories. Save your Cimarron 1873 Repeating to your Gun Vault for ongoing value tracking and alerts on comparable sales.